Should You Wear A Helmet When Skiing?
Friday, February 25th, 2011Should you or should you not wear a ski helmet when skiing?
Dr Gerhard Ruedl from the Department of Sport Science at the University of Innsbruck says that there is evidence that ski helmets protect against head injury, and that one way to increase the use of helmets would be to make them included with ski hire. And, following some highly publicised deaths the issue has got a lot of press recently.
A recent study concluded that general head injury was reduced by 35% when helmets were worn, and this number increased to 59% for children under the age of 13.
But would wearing helmets actually make skiing safer? The issue needs to be looked a from the view point of how we, humans, deal with risk. Their are certain cases where changes are made, ostensibly, to make people safer, which in fact don’t.
With the advent of ABS braking – an innovation that greatly improves a cars breaking ability – you would expect to find that you would have safer drievrs. This wasn’t the case. Supplying drivers with ABS actually made them worse drivers: breaking harder, driving faster, tailgating other cars more often. So the introduction of ABS didn’t reduce the rate of accidents. So what happened? Drivers were consuming the extra risk reduction, they could now drive faster and more dangerously for the same risk as before. This type of risk homeostasis doesn’t happen all the time, but it does happen often enugh that it should be consideerd.
So where does this fit in with ski helmets? Ski helmets may provide a fasle sense of security, resulting in faster skiing and riskier behaviour which in itself could lead to more accidents.
Overall the authors believed that the evidence points to helmets having a protective effect and that we should increase the use of helmets. But then that’s what they thought about ABS. Food for thought…
Related articles
- Helmets reduced ski injuries (lv.com)
- Ski helmet use ‘makes sense’ (bbc.co.uk)
- Ski helmets have a lesson for us … on ‘localism’ (boris-johnson.com)





