The Rational Optimist And Cheese
Tuesday, January 25th, 2011- Image via Wikipedia
Human beings learn skills from each other by imitation. Mistakes occur, sometimes there are improvements, and thus our skill set and culture evolves. The bigger the connected population the more invention, and the more culture progresses.
Conversely, the smaller the population, the more self sufficient the group, the less is invented. A small grouping of settlers cannot sustain more than a certain number of tools. People can only learn a limited set of skills, and if there are not enough people to learn and pass on that skill then that skill will be lost. Progress can regress.
Or though runs the theory of Matt Ridley in the Rational Optimist. And I think he could be right.
Take Chamonix in the 18th/19th Century, an isolated mountain valley with a small self sufficient population, little trade and a harsh living environment. There weren’t enough peiple to learn and pass on skills so the alpine diet regressed. No gourmet French food back then just the odd marmot, cheese and stale bread.
Without a large enough population the inhabitants of Chamonix weren’t able to have a rich and varied diet. For them the only food set they managed to retain was stale bread and cheese otherwise known as fondue, raclette or croute. Now obviously hailed as regional specialities. What we now know though is that the Chamonix folk had simply forgotten how to cook anything else, and it wasn’t until the ‘discovery’ of Chamonix (by the English) and the opening up of tourism and trade that cuisine, and life in general, began to improve.
Related articles
- Digesting a fondue from the inside out (newscientist.com)
- Fondue: It’s a cheesy Seventies revival (independent.co.uk)


